I need a good mitten for those single digit and below days. I downloaded the fit guide and I'm half way between the 9 & 10 line. I was near a shop that sells Hestra so I stopped in to double check sizes and see what they still had available. The 10 mitten they had felt a big big but the 9 was definitely too small & the 11 was way too big. When I got home I ordered the Army mitten in a 10. They arrived yesterday but they seem smaller than the Hestra 10's I tried on in the store. When my fingers are extended straight the tips are tightly against the end. When my hand is in its natural curve they seem like they may be okay. These are my first mitts since I was a kid. How do yours fit? Did I get a short pair or do you mitten folks think I'm good?