It's down to 2: Michelin Pilot Exalto A-S and BF Goodrich g-Force Supersport A-S; thankfully, there aren't all that many good tires in a 185-60-14. In the past I've liked Pilots in the rain, but they were too flexy in the dry, on a heavier car though. I've also had good luck with BF Goodrich.
No cords showing yet, but I don't think I'd be able to get a flat fixed on warranty. If I don't get a flat, I "might" make it to snow season on the OEM tires, so I have some time to decide.