Quote:
Originally Posted by
Living Proof 
One funny aspect of the TV hype about Tiger's future, is that there is one major, major golf commentator/color analyst who fell from the very top of the pro tour almost overnight.
One day Johnny Miller was on the verge of joining the greatest then lost is so quick, never to recover. How come he does not compare Tiger to himself?
Miller was a great player but he never had the sustained dominance of Tiger. Even he recognizes that he was never the putter or the consistently dominant player that Tiger was at his best. Johnny just had days where he was THAT good.
Tom Watson is a closer comparison. He took longer to win big consistently the way Tiger did, but once he did he was a remarkable winner, Majors especially (all 8 wins from 75-83) including taking down Nicklaus head to head a couple of times. At his peak he was a fearless putter and chipper. Then one day he stopped making putts. It's not like he was done done (as evidenced by the 09 Open Ch, which would have been the greatest sports victory ever!), but he just stopped winning like he once did. How many more Majors would Watson have won, considering how spectacularly he still hits the ball now, if he just could have regained his putting stroke and confidence? Unfortunately for these guys at that level, once they lose their edge on the greens they just never seem to get it all the way back.
This may be Tiger. Doesnt mean he didn't have the greatest run ever, or that he cant win a Bay Hill or even a major or two, but if the putts don't drop consistently it is pretty unreasonable for anyone to expect him to have what would essentially be another upper echelon Hall of Fame level career starting from now in order to pass Nicklaus. It isn't impossible, just unlikely with injury issues and putts that don't drop.